EDIT: I apparently assumed y'all have read/seen the book/movie and that
was lazy on my part so here comes the spoiler Alert synopsis of The Hunger Games so you can decipher what I wrote bellow. SPOILER ALERTS! (fer seriousness)
TL;DR? The movie isn't 'great' but it's not awful. it's far to long for the content it covers but everyone in the film does their level best to turn in a watchable performance. If I were to give it a star rating I would give it some stars. which is more than none and less than some more stars and way less than ALL THE STARS!.
Katniss is this girl who live in future 'merka. where there are twelve districts all slaving away in service to the 'capitol'. Katniss lives in district twelve which is coal country, everything there is gray/black. She takes care of her sister, her sisters pain in the ass meat sack of a pet cat, and her mom who's basically tuned out sense her husband died. Katniss is a super good bow hunter but the only place she can hunt is in the woods beyond the very rarely turned on electric fence boundaries of district twelve. Her best buddy Gale is also a super good trap hunter and together they feed their families and try to make ends meet. Sounds pretty lower middle class except this world has a terrible yearly ritual of torture called The Hunger Games. Where each district offers up a boy and a girl to fight to the death on television and its against the law to NOT watch. Katniss' little sister gets called up and Katniss volunteers instead, then Peta is the boy and they get wisked away to the capitol on a super fast spacetrain and Haymitch (A past district 12 winner) is all "you guys suck...like a lot.) and Katniss stares at things cause well shes kinda in, shock I guess. Anywho they go to the capitol which is sorta like hot topic but fifty years from now when all the cool kids are old and tired. Haymitch tells Katniss and Peta to make people like them if they want to win the other kids range from shitty to awesome and we see freaky peoples of all colors and styles, then Lenny Kravitz has gold eye shadow and dresses Katniss in flammable material and they become friends and he's too cool for words. Then the kids ride chariots cause chariots are cool now! and Stanly Tucci is awesome and his hair is sorta blue and kind of creepy. And there's training and Peta throws a big rock type metal ball thing to intimidate the other kids and Rue is doing her Spiderman thing (Rue is from district 11, the 'grains' district) and finally the kids get rated for their lethality and potential to sell action figures and everyone is shocked because Katniss pulled a William Tell and that got her an 11 out of 12 so her action figure will have bow shooting action and accessories! Then the kids get flown to the Hunger Games site and put in their own special launching tubes which put them near the cornocopia and there's all kinds of supplies and kids start killing each other and Katniss runs away with a sack of slightly useful supplies and sleeps in trees, gets hunted by the cool kids, which include Peta (sadness) and they Rue's in another tree cause she's spiderman and points out these geneticly mutated bees called tracker jackers and Katniss drops them on the cool kids and some of them die and Katniss goes a bit wonky in the head cause she got stung and that's super poisonous and Rue takes care of her during her nightmare coma time and their friends now and have a tea party that includes blowing up the popular kids camp full of supplies and food, but Rue dies cause this kid spears her in the chest but Katniss is all "bitches aint making this death cheap! NO SIR!" so she sings and plants flowers around Rue's body and District 11 see's this on the TV and is all "YEAH WE'RE GONNA BURN THIS MUTHER DOWN! *&&^% YOUR COUCH!" and then the cyborgs from THX 1138 kill all of them :( So Katniss finds Peta who's apparently a T-1000 cause he's super good at morphing into other things (He painted himself to look like a flat river rock...it's only slightly unbelieveable.) And they have a moment in cave with the hugging and some kissing and they get a gift from the audience to keep Peta alive but its some soup which is pretty much a way for Haymitch to say "play it up you slut." and they have a conversation about their lives cause well there are fans watching, and then theres an announcement that there are special treats for everyone and Katniss goes to get the stuff to keep peta alive and the other kid from district 11 saves Katniss' life by killing knife girl. The last few kids get killed off and then there's dog things that chase Peta, Katniss and Kato back to the Cornocopia and Peta and Katniss think that they could both with cause dismebodied annoucner voice said they could both with, Kato gets eaten by the dogs but slowly and Katniss offs him with an arrow out of mercy and the disembodied voice is all "sike one of you must kill the other." so Katniss is like "*&^% this game and tells Peta they should both eat killerdeth berries and then the disembodied voice is all "double sike you both win #1 sexy victory dance time! They get picked up, theres post interviews and they get sent home, the guy who was in charge of the game controls is killed by the president of the central district and Peta and Katniss return home as heroes but Gale is all sad cause he saw them make kissy face on the TV....THE (TO BE CONTINUED) END.
First things first. I read the books, all three of them. Didn't hate the first two at all. But Suzanne Collins is a sadist. Pure and simple, her narrative practically sleeps through the first half until people start killing each other and all of a sudden her prose comes alive and you can practically tell that her word count per day went through the roof. Her story is about the kids killing each other, everything else was fluff her publishers demanded so they could sell this as "YA Sci-Fi".
TL;DR? The movie isn't 'great' but it's not awful. it's far to long for the content it covers but everyone in the film does their level best to turn in a watchable performance. If I were to give it a star rating I would give it some stars. which is more than none and less than some more stars and way less than ALL THE STARS!.
Katniss is this girl who live in future 'merka. where there are twelve districts all slaving away in service to the 'capitol'. Katniss lives in district twelve which is coal country, everything there is gray/black. She takes care of her sister, her sisters pain in the ass meat sack of a pet cat, and her mom who's basically tuned out sense her husband died. Katniss is a super good bow hunter but the only place she can hunt is in the woods beyond the very rarely turned on electric fence boundaries of district twelve. Her best buddy Gale is also a super good trap hunter and together they feed their families and try to make ends meet. Sounds pretty lower middle class except this world has a terrible yearly ritual of torture called The Hunger Games. Where each district offers up a boy and a girl to fight to the death on television and its against the law to NOT watch. Katniss' little sister gets called up and Katniss volunteers instead, then Peta is the boy and they get wisked away to the capitol on a super fast spacetrain and Haymitch (A past district 12 winner) is all "you guys suck...like a lot.) and Katniss stares at things cause well shes kinda in, shock I guess. Anywho they go to the capitol which is sorta like hot topic but fifty years from now when all the cool kids are old and tired. Haymitch tells Katniss and Peta to make people like them if they want to win the other kids range from shitty to awesome and we see freaky peoples of all colors and styles, then Lenny Kravitz has gold eye shadow and dresses Katniss in flammable material and they become friends and he's too cool for words. Then the kids ride chariots cause chariots are cool now! and Stanly Tucci is awesome and his hair is sorta blue and kind of creepy. And there's training and Peta throws a big rock type metal ball thing to intimidate the other kids and Rue is doing her Spiderman thing (Rue is from district 11, the 'grains' district) and finally the kids get rated for their lethality and potential to sell action figures and everyone is shocked because Katniss pulled a William Tell and that got her an 11 out of 12 so her action figure will have bow shooting action and accessories! Then the kids get flown to the Hunger Games site and put in their own special launching tubes which put them near the cornocopia and there's all kinds of supplies and kids start killing each other and Katniss runs away with a sack of slightly useful supplies and sleeps in trees, gets hunted by the cool kids, which include Peta (sadness) and they Rue's in another tree cause she's spiderman and points out these geneticly mutated bees called tracker jackers and Katniss drops them on the cool kids and some of them die and Katniss goes a bit wonky in the head cause she got stung and that's super poisonous and Rue takes care of her during her nightmare coma time and their friends now and have a tea party that includes blowing up the popular kids camp full of supplies and food, but Rue dies cause this kid spears her in the chest but Katniss is all "bitches aint making this death cheap! NO SIR!" so she sings and plants flowers around Rue's body and District 11 see's this on the TV and is all "YEAH WE'RE GONNA BURN THIS MUTHER DOWN! *&&^% YOUR COUCH!" and then the cyborgs from THX 1138 kill all of them :( So Katniss finds Peta who's apparently a T-1000 cause he's super good at morphing into other things (He painted himself to look like a flat river rock...it's only slightly unbelieveable.) And they have a moment in cave with the hugging and some kissing and they get a gift from the audience to keep Peta alive but its some soup which is pretty much a way for Haymitch to say "play it up you slut." and they have a conversation about their lives cause well there are fans watching, and then theres an announcement that there are special treats for everyone and Katniss goes to get the stuff to keep peta alive and the other kid from district 11 saves Katniss' life by killing knife girl. The last few kids get killed off and then there's dog things that chase Peta, Katniss and Kato back to the Cornocopia and Peta and Katniss think that they could both with cause dismebodied annoucner voice said they could both with, Kato gets eaten by the dogs but slowly and Katniss offs him with an arrow out of mercy and the disembodied voice is all "sike one of you must kill the other." so Katniss is like "*&^% this game and tells Peta they should both eat killerdeth berries and then the disembodied voice is all "double sike you both win #1 sexy victory dance time! They get picked up, theres post interviews and they get sent home, the guy who was in charge of the game controls is killed by the president of the central district and Peta and Katniss return home as heroes but Gale is all sad cause he saw them make kissy face on the TV....THE (TO BE CONTINUED) END.
First things first. I read the books, all three of them. Didn't hate the first two at all. But Suzanne Collins is a sadist. Pure and simple, her narrative practically sleeps through the first half until people start killing each other and all of a sudden her prose comes alive and you can practically tell that her word count per day went through the roof. Her story is about the kids killing each other, everything else was fluff her publishers demanded so they could sell this as "YA Sci-Fi".
So if the killing of children is what works in her books
then why would they make a movie about it? Because the fluff garbage about the
future society and districts actually sort of works, she accidentally built an
interesting world with some depth, and I say accidentally because where she
could have delved into the psychological effects of using death and destruction
to shape a society through fear and totalitarian control over decades she
doesn't really care about that because she wants to tell a story about kids
killing each other for cash and prizes. She fails on almost every level to
develop her world of perversion and sickness beyond the basic metaphors she
needs to let everyone know that anyone who would enjoy kids killing each other
for any reason is a soulless sadist. which is what her stories about so there
is a HUGE amount of Irony in the books that we never really touch on or
inspect. Which is great because we elevate that irony to near epic levels for
the movie.
We all just watched a movie about kids killing each other
for the benefit of some twisted future society, we're supposed to feel joy for
the heroes and shame and anger for the corrupted society and those who enjoy
its fruits, but here's the twist, WE JUST WATCHED IT ALL HAPPEN. The film
makers realized this conundrum and in order to separate the audience from ever
putting two and two together that they are by association part of the sickness
we took a rated R story and brought it down to PG through the magic of really,
really, REALLY shitty camera work. half the time I couldn't tell if the camera
guys were bored or they tagged Michael J. Fox in to run the camera. See you
can't feel revulsion for people who would willingly watch the forced murder of
innocent children (which is you the viewer. You should be revolted by your own
willingness to see this) if you cant see any god damn thing except for this
tree, and some grass and look rocks and a river and a hey a pretty girl running
away from fire, root for her!!!
Make no mistake, there are dark, horrible questions in the
murky parts of Hunger Games, but this movie is about a half assed love
triangle, and beating the odds, we won't ask why a society of so many would
allow them selves to be tortured by so few. Or what kind of society lives for watching
children kill each other on national television. No we will only focus on the
Girl on fire, and Rue, poor poor Rue, and the evil Capitol district with their
strange perversions of fashion and morals.
I have already mentioned the camera work being awful and it
comes back again and again, they should be ashamed. The pacing is pretty awful
too, and the horrible failure to pay attention to detail destroys almost every
bit of hard work the cast did to develop what little character they were given
to work with. Elizabeth Banks killed it, same with Stanly Tucci, and Woody
Harrelson. Josh Hutcherson and Jennifer Lawrence did a workable job with what
little they were given to build on but every few minutes something happened
that made me cringe. Katniss waits far to long to save her sister by
volunteering for tribute, its supposed to make you fear for the little girl but
Katniss needed to be right in there like a reflex action and it just drags on
for what feels like forever, it hurts her character because they focus on the
sister and not on Katniss' reaction to the event so you don't know where her
head is at because you can't see her face, by the time she steps up you start
to wonder if she gives a shit about her family at all. Not to mention that you
loose all the thinking that she did in the book, and they don't ever once try
and connect you with her emotionally other than showing her from these half
assed quarter shots where she stares at random shit, this does NOTHING to relay
her internal voice or emotional turmoil, for that we either need to see her
wrestle with things in her eyes, her mind or with OTHER PEOPLE. Also seeing
them approach the food like they are starving would have been nice. I believed
the book being called the Hunger Games, the movie should have been called
"Skipped Lunch" Games.
The fire on Katniss and Peta was nice but pretty lazy on the
CG side, felt very slap dash quit your bitching we save quality FX for oscar
contenders!!!
The books are just as guilty of making Katniss passive and
boring but I honesty feel like of all the things they could have fixed for the
movie making her more proactive or getting her out of her own damned head was
something that NEEDED to happen, She has NO character arc, she makes plenty of
decisions but the world just kind of happens around her nothing in her changes
in this first book at all and the same thing happens for the movie, on every
level Peta is a more interesting character, Rue is a more interesting
character, Katniss is basically the first Hipster hero, she's too cool to every
let any of this shit change her for either better or worse. I didn't care about
her at all until WELL into the third book and by then I hated the turn of
events the author had chosen because the whole story is about sadistically
hurting the readers as much as possible. And the movie is so antiseptic
compared to the book that its basically a different story, there's almost none
of the inherent soullessness of the capitol in the game, the wolves lack the
human faces, the violence is shakey cam'd away, we get more of Haymitch's
politicking but other than that the capitol feels very much like a reject city
from the Star Wars Prequels and I cannot for the life of me muster any hatred
or like for it at all.
Why did the kids let Peta behind them while hunting Katniss?
He could have taken out the back two before the front two knew what was up, the
third girl dead before Kato can turn and Peta and Kato die together. WHY THE
FUCK DID THEY SLEEP NEAR HIM, stupid idiot should have slit all their throats
nice and quiet, these moments ruin Peta for me, I don't understand why they
showed them sleeping or wandering around as a group with Peta, in the books you
assume they don't trust him and the author NEVER gives you reason to doubt
that, but Peta had NUMEROUS chances to kill these idiots of almost or
completely scott free.
LOVED the district 11 response to Rue, which was the ONLY
part of her death I gave a crap about at all in this, all the parts from the
book were in the movie but they were disconnected and given no chance to breathe
so there was no pain, no emotion to it, but the district 11 response was
AWESOME. Although a dangerous choice as a film maker because I wanted to stay
there and follow that story more thani wanted to go back to Katniss. This was
building on a series of events and people were making active decisions based on
a situation and that is interesting, also they aren't the main character so
there are lives at stake and I VERY QUICKLY care about these people with out
even knowing a single one of them or hearing ANY of them speak. But no back to
the main storyline.
The Cornucopia looks like the EMP building got an erection,
and that's not what I would call good design. The dogs are wasted, the whole
sadistic horror of the end is just PG'd away. Did I miss something or did the
black guy from 11 never get killed? Did they just sort of 'screw it no one really cares' a character
away? YAY they win cause apparently a TV show about kids fighting to the death
is only acceptable if someone lives through the whole mess, its just barbaric
if EVERYONE dies!
Stanly Tucci thank you for making this somewhat watch able,
you are quite the performer sir. And shove in one more pathetic attempt at that
pointless love triangle before the credits and we're out!
No comments:
Post a Comment